The privacy worries with smart cities

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

Momentum for smart cities projects, which has been fed by big promises from industry and big hopes in government, is slowing down in the face of a wave of public skepticism.

Driving the news: Alphabet-owned Sidewalk Labs, which has proposed a futuristic smart-city development for Toronto's waterfront, has pledged not to sell personal data collected at the project or use it for advertising to assuage privacy concerns.

  • Instead, if the plan is approved, local government entities will take the lead on managing data.

Context: "The U.S. has a general optimism that technology can make our lives easier if used in right way. But that’s countered by mistrust of intentions or capabilities of state and local governments," said Todd Daubert, chair of the communication and technology practice at Dentons, a law firm that works on smart city developments.

There's also distrust of the tech companies that see cities as a huge market for selling their data-guzzling tools.

  • Sidewalk Labs originally proposed an independent "urban data trust" to manage the data collected in Toronto's Quayside project.
  • But residents and city officials were uneasy about how it would work, and lack of clarity around Sidewalk's business model spurred opposition.
  • The company has now pledged to minimize data collection and to build only about 25% of the technology systems used.
  • Sidewalk's concessions "shows that Waterfront Toronto was able to stand up to Big Tech — not kick them out but not be bullied by them either," said Alex Ryan, SVP of partnerships at MaRS Discovery District, an innovation hub in Toronto. "People don't want it to be just Big Tech doing this development."

What's happening: Projects in other cities have hit snags.

  • Kansas City, Mo., is scrapping a city office responsible for managing civic technologies in favor of a 12-person board to advise on future projects, per StateScoop.
  • A watchdog group sued San Diego for not disclosing data collected by sensors and cameras via its controversial Smart Street Lights Program, per the San Diego Union-Tribune.

The big picture: Growth of smart city developments has been slower than predicted, but plenty of data-intensive technologies have been deployed in cities around the world.

  • Camera-equipped drones are used by public safety to monitor traffic, crowded areas and severe weather or emergencies.
  • Social networking monitoring lets local officials track citizen sentiment via Facebook and Twitter feeds to keep tabs on chatter and complaints.
  • Location beacons at airports, transit stations, malls or stadiums can connect to your phone to detect when you are nearby.

Cities have been aggressive at putting in safeguards against technologies like facial recognition, and some are trying to forge data-governance agreements with the companies operating there.

  • Many data collection points start out as discrete projects. But as the amount of data being collected and exchanged increases, so do concerns that it may be compromised.
  • Going forward, city governments must get smarter about sharing the insights from the data collected, not the data itself, said Daubert.

"Generally speaking, city officials are incredibly cognizant of data privacy and doing what they can to meet concerns of people, largely because of what they’ve seen in the private sector," said Brooks Rainwater, director of city solutions at the National League of Cities. "That puts people in a place where they are asking more questions as these new services come online."

The bottom line: "This is something that every city globally is going to be dealing with in the next 5 years," Ryan said.

Map: Aïda Amer/Axios

Additional Stories

Australia's deadly fires: What you need to know

The Australian flag flies under red skies from fires on Jan. 4 in Bruthen, Victoria. Photos: Darrian Traynor/Getty Images

Scores of fires continue to rage across Australian after weekend weather exacerbated one of Australia's worst wildfire seasons in recorded history.

The impact: Since Australia's bushfire season began in September, 24 people have been killed. More than 1,500 homes have been lost, Prime Minister Scott Morrison noted. Tens of thousands of acres of forest land and national parks have burned.

The latest: Iran tweets response to Trump's threat to target cultural sites

Photo: Mohammed Sawaf/AFP via Getty Images

Iran's foreign minister tweeted Sunday the U.S. committed "committed grave breaches" of international law by killing a top Iranian general in Iraq and that President Trump's threats to attack the country's cultural sites "is a WAR CRIME."

The latest: Mohammad Javad Zarif used Twitter to directly respond to Trump, who spent much of Sunday night tweeting threats to Iran, including that the U.S. had "targeted 52 Iranian sites."

Al-Shabab claims attack on military base used by U.S. and Kenyan forces

Photo: Google Maps screenshot

A military base in Kenya's Lamu County where U.S. and Kenyan military personnel was attacked Sunday morning, Kenya Defence Forces confirmed in a statement.

Details: The U.S. Africa Command tweeted that it's "monitoring the situation" following the attack on Manda Bay Airfield claimed by al Qaeda branch Al-Shabab.

Samsung sets Feb. 11 for next big phone launch

Samsung

Samsung has set Feb. 11 in San Francisco as the date and place for its next Unpacked event, where it is expected to launch the next high-end Galaxy smartphone as well as a new foldable device.

Why it matters: The event is being held earlier than past Galaxy launches and its announcement comes after the date was revealed in a leaked video. It comes in between next week's CES in Las Vegas and February's Mobile World Congress, a traditional launching point for smartphones.

  • The image in the teaser that accompanied Samsung's invitation squares with the rumors of a more square-shaped foldable phone than the current Galaxy Fold.

White House informs Congress of Soleimani strike, Trump warns U.S. will hit Iran if attacked

Trump speaks at a 'Evangelicals for Trump' Coalition event on Jan. 3. Photo: Stringer/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

The White House has notified Congress of the drone strike that killed top Iranian commander Qasem Soleimani, fulfilling its duties under the War Powers Act.

Why it matters: House Speaker Nancy Pelosi  (D-Calif.) said the notification "raises more questions than it answers." Both Democrats and Republicans — including  and Sens. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) and Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) — have criticized President Trump for not obtaining congressional approval for this week's strike.

Pelosi: Classified War Powers Act alert on Iran raises more questions

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi during a December news conference at the U.S. Capitol. Photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said in a statement on Saturday evening that she's dissatisfied with President Trump's War Powers notification regarding Iran.

What she's saying: "This classified War Powers Act notification delivered to Congress raises more questions than it answers," Pelosi said, adding the document "prompts serious and urgent questions about the timing" of the U.S. military strike that killed top Iranian commander Qasem Soleimani in Iraq.

Go deeper: White House informs Congress of Soleimani strike, Trump warns U.S. will hit Iran if attacked

After Iran strike, Kaepernick blasts "American terrorist attacks against Black and Brown people"

Colin Kaepernick at his NFL workout on Nov. 16, 2019 in Riverdale, Georgia. Photo: Carmen Mandato/Getty Images

NFL quarterback and political activist Colin Kaepernick denounced "America militarism" on Saturday, following a U.S. strike in Iraq that killed top Iranian general Qasem Soleimani.

Between the lines: It's unclear if Kaepernick is directly denouncing the attack on Soleimani — since he does not explicitly reference him — or if he's using the Iranian commander's death as an opportunity to broadly criticize U.S. military involvement in the Middle East.

Thousands in Baghdad gather, mourn loss of Iran's top general

Photo: Popular Mobilization Forces Media Office, Iraq, via AP

In Baghdad Saturday, thousands of Iraqi mourners held a funeral procession for Qasem Soleimani, chanting: "America is the Great Satan," AP reports.

Context: Soleimani's body will be sent back to his hometown in Iran where he will be buried after the funeral processions in Iraq are completed, BBC writes. Iraqis are also mourning the death of Abu Mahdi al-Muhandis, a senior Iraqi militia commander who was killed in the same drone strike, per AP.

Read more at Axios
© Copyright Axios 2020